Foot in mouth diseaseMichael Gorman, president-elect of ALA, seems to be suffering from this lately. The latest example of this is his participation in an e-mail symposium with three other librarians who are involved in digitization to discuss the impact of the Google digitization project. Gorman uses hyperbole and invective, at the same time in one instance: "Any user of Google knows that it is pathetic as an information-retrieval system", and comes off as being an out-of-touch blowhard. Unless you get American Libraries delivered to you, the article, "Google at the Gates", is only available online at the moment to ALA members (it's in the March 2005, 36(3) 40-3, issue). There is a great discussion, with some excerpting, over at
LISNews if neither of those situations apply to you. My favorite point in those discussions was that if Gorman is trying to make a case that you shouldn't get rid of librarians in the wake of Google's latest endeavor, why didn't he make suggestions as to how his concerns could be addressed? The other three participants were quite knowledgeable and reasoned in their responses in my opinion. They addressed problems that they saw with the program, but they also had suggestions on what should be considered when addressing those challenges.
This brings up another issue. ALA elections are right around the corner. What are some questions that you want the candidates for president-elect to answer? Keeping in mind Gorman's recent actions, what would raise red flags for you in our candidates? For me, it's not Gorman's stances on Google or bloggers (he does have some good points) that raise the red flag (too late) for me, it's the way that he expresses himself. Being president, or president-elect in this case, of anything is a thankless position. You have to keep in mind, though, that you're in a position whereby you are under a higher level of scrutiny and that your actions not only reflect on you, but also on the organization/business/country that you are associated with. That's a big reason why
Boeing ousted their CEO yesterday. Mr. Gorman needs to realize that his comments, whether or not he intends them as such, will be taken as collective view of the library profession every time that he signs as "President-Elect of the American Library Association."